Over-cooked is right! I make no bones about it. I call it over-processing when you go beyond the normal color correcting, levels, sharpening etc. Its not for every picture or for every person, that's for sure.
Just like HDR, Orton, solarization and what ever manipulations are out there, this one is the current fad in some circles and it will run it's course.
But for now, I am having fun and learning a new skill set. I am getting requests from customers to process images like this.
I am sure, as with any excessive manipulation, there is a lot of information cast away - but at least I always have the original to go back to.
Have Fun!
Jeff